A test game using my Axis & Allies* naval, adapted for hexagons, rules.
It’s a lovely day, so I decided to play a short wargame in the garden. I have three lightweight trestle tables, each 60 x 100cm and 95cm tall, so I took them from the Shedquarters and set them up on the patio area. I covered them with my somewhat bright blue hexagon cloth, clipped it to the table edges and set to.
Situation. A convoy of merchant ships, escorted by two British destroyers, is approaching a screen of German submarines in the North Atlantic.
The submarines submerged. Each is replaced by one real submerged token and 1d6/2 dummies (rounding down). They all look the same, but the real subs are marked with a number on the bottom and the dummies with a small ‘x’.
Both destroyers have the “Sub Hunter” special rule, so after each German turn, they turn and move 3 hexagons towards the nearest German submarine. This turn is deducted from their next maximum move. I decided to change the operation of this rule, see below.
The two destroyers went after the nearest contacts and the convoy was ordered to make best speed, so some of the larger ships increased to maximum speed of 4 hexagons. (around 22 knots)
The entire convoy of 16 merchant ships was now spread over a length of 15 hexagons, or around 3000 yards.
Two submarines closed on HMS Hasty. One was a dummy, and after declaring its attack was removed from the table. The other fired a torpedo at the destroyer’s port bow at 1 hex (around 200 yards) range.
Two dice were rolled: 5 and 2. One hit was scored for the 5. (4 and 5 score 1 hit, 6 scores 2 hits). One point of hull damage was caused, and with only one hull point remaining the ship was marked as “crippled”, losing one point from armour, vital armour and speed.
Hasty swung to port and depth-charged the sub, with five dice scoring 6,6,5,4,3 for six hits. With hull points of 1 and vital armour of 5 the submarine sank immediately. I decided to adjust the depth charge rule as well (see below).
HMS Herward also depth-charged and sank a submarine with two hits.
Meanwhile Penguin and Countryman, two of the faster ships, both swung to starboard to avoid the destroyers operating in their paths.
The other ships ploughed on at about 12 knots. One of the cargo ships on the edge of the convoy was struck and began to sink immediately.
The destroyers chased another two targets, both of which turned out to be false contacts.
Three more submarines lined up to attack the convoy but two, on declaring their attack, were revealed as dummies. The third failed to hit the Atlantic, a large tanker.
Hereward depth-charged another dummy U-boat. With several wrecks in the process of sinking, ships were now having to take avoiding action to avoid collisions.
Another cargo ship was struck by a torpedo near the centre of the convoy. She continued, crippled. Hereward steamed for the location and sank the last of the German submarines. The convoy proceeded towards Liverpool.
Losses. One cargo ship lost and one crippled. HMS Hasty crippled. Three U-boats sunk. A good day for the Royal Navy.
Rule changes to be applied.
Depth charges. Rather than rolling 5 dice for hits on any submarine adjacent to the rear half of the destroyer, I will apply the same system of splitting the dice as I do for gunnery. Thus the depth charges are thrown in a pattern into the three adjacent hexagons to starboard rear, starboard port and directly astern. Up to 1/3 of the dice available, rounding up, may be used for each hex, provided that the total number is not exceeded.
Targeting 5 dice at 1 hex is overkill, because it only needs 1 hit to sink most submarines. With 1 die there is a 50% chance, with 2 dice a 75% chance and with 5 dice almost 97% chance of rolling 4,5 or 6 on at least one of them.
Sub Hunter. Rather than arbitrarily moving the ship at the end of the enemy move, I decided that a destroyer with this special rule must at the start of its turn roll a die and immediately head for the nearest enemy submarine within 1D6 hexagons, notwithstanding any search pattern she is working to.
All in all a fun little test game, and I think with the rule tweaks the submarines might have a better chance of surviving more than one destroyer sweep.
* “Axis and Allies” and “War at Sea” are copyright to Wizards of the Coast, and the use of their original rule concepts is acknowledged.